Thursday is a day to give thanks, to be with family … and to fill one’s face with scoops of stuffing before the tryptophan kicks in. To help make yours a holiday to remember, we asked 10 foodies near and far to share their best Thanksgiving tips.
Emily Dupuis
Director of food service, Champaign school district
“1. For super-flavorful mashed potatoes, boil potatoes in vegetable broth and sliced leeks. Mashed potatoes can have a tendency to be bland if you don’t season them right.
“I like to season from the get-go and infuse my potatoes with flavor while cooking them. Use your favorite veggie broth — I love the Better Than Bouillon paste — and slice up some leeks to boil along with your potatoes. Leeks are in the onion family and have a super mild onion/garlicky flavor when cooked down — the perfect pairing with mashed potatoes, in my opinion.
“Simply strain and mash potatoes as you normally would. You can leave the sliced leeks in for an extra pop of flavor, or discard them.
“2. Everyone loves leftovers, right? If you plan on packing up leftovers to family or friends, ask them to bring along their own takeaway containers so you aren’t scrambling for Tupperware that you’ll likely never see again or putting cranberry sauce in a Ziplock bag because you ran out of containers.
“3. Clean and declutter your fridge before the big day. Not only will a messy fridge caked with old ketchup or soy sauce not be very appetizing to see if you have guests going in and out of the fridge, but having a clean and organized fridge will ensure proper airflow so that your temperatures remain out of the temperature danger zone.
“It also means you will have adequate space for storage of food and can easily grab anything you might need.
“4. Don’t forgo food safety. In the comfort of our own kitchens, it’s easy to get a little lax when it comes to making sure we are washing our hands regularly, letting food sit out a little too long on the counter or going in for a taste test with our fingers.
“Biggest takeaways: make sure cold foods stay cold, and hot foods stay hot. Wash hands often and change cutting boards after handling raw meat products and then ready-to-eat foods. When we host, we have to not only be mindful of preparing delicious food, but safe food for our guests.”
Jin Hwan Park
Owner, Sakanaya
“You cooked on Thanksgiving — let everyone roll their own dinner the next day.
“Turn leftover turkey into a make-your-own-hand-roll night. Shred the turkey and warm it in a covered skillet with a splash of broth to keep it moist. Once thoroughly reheated, uncover, let any excess liquid cook off and toss with a little teriyaki sauce.
“Set out small sheets of nori (roasted seaweed), warm rice, cucumber, avocado and store-bought spicy mayo. Everyone can fill and fold their own rolls at the table — no sushi mat or special skills needed.
“Make them one at a time and eat right away while the seaweed is still crisp. The leftovers become a new meal, and the cook gets to sit down with everyone else.”
Nancy Fuller
Host, Food Network’s ‘Farmhouse Rules’
“My family is so large that the leftovers are scarce, but if you’re left with a bit of sweet potato casserole with maple syrup and marshmallows and a few bites of winter squash, plus a grocery-store pie crust … it’s a brand new pie. And delicious.
“Thanksgiving soup is another favorite. I know it doesn’t sound right to even consider it, but use that little bit of gravy, stuffing, mashed potato, turkey bits, meat off the leg and thigh — if there is any left — and add a little more broth and a tablespoon of Bell’s seasoning … soup. More deliciousness.”
Drew and Jessica Smith.
Owner, Smith Burger Company
“My biggest Thanksgiving tip is simple: Brine your turkey.
“It seems like every year, the turkey ends up being the driest and least-exciting part of an otherwise great Thanksgiving meal. Taking the extra time to brine your turkey before cooking makes a huge difference.
“It helps retain moisture, adds flavor and gives you a much juicier, more tender bird.
“It’s a simple extra step that can make the turkey one of the best parts of the meal instead of the most disappointing.”
Chris Lehmann
Area manager and food-truck GM, Subwars
“Bring your own Tupperware for leftovers. It’s a pro move. A veteran move, some say.
“Whoever is hosting will thank you for not stealing theirs. You know there will be leftovers.”
Jeffrey and Lauren Brokish
Co-owner, Pekara Bakery and Bistro, Central Illinois Bakehouse, Martinelli’s Market, Prairie Fruits Farm and Creamery, Salt Fork Food Works, Espresso Royale cafes and The Literary
“My biggest tip is to use a mix of breads that are a little stale for your stuffing.
“Cut them into cubes the day before and let it sit out over night. The bread will absorb the drippings and more flavor if it goes into your recipe a little dry.
“I still make my grandmother’s recipe using a mix of rye and white sourdough breads, and I highly recommended the breads from Central Illinois Bakehouse.
“They’re made fresh daily here in town using Illinois-grown wheat and rye, available at Martinelli’s, Pekara and all local Schnucks and Neimanns.”
Harold Dieterle
Season 1 winner, Bravo’s ‘Top Chef’
“I have been playing with different leftover sandwich constructs, including a stuffing-gravy hybrid, which is really amazing. You have to eat it immediately, though — otherwise, the bread gets a little soggy.
“The sandwich ingredients: toasted sourdough bread, roasted turkey breast, roasted sweet potatoes and stuffing gravy, with jellied cranberry sauce smeared on the toasted bread.”
Tiffany Derry
Season 7 fan-favorite award winner, ‘Top Chef’
“If you are left with mounds of leftovers, I’m going to need you to work on portions next year. LOL.
“Seriously, though, if you found yourself with lots of braised greens, go ahead and freeze all of it. I get it — I normally want to get rid of everything because I’m so tired of all of it, but that feeling will pass and you will have a wonderful side later that requires minimum time to heat.
“There are many dishes that would do well in the freezer so make your freezer your friend.
“Next, it’s soup season. Using turkey or ham, let it simmer all day and then add in some veggies or even pasta at the end. If you have roasted carrots or squash, add all that in the last minute.
“I love repurposing a meal and finishing with fresh herbs and some lemon zest. It works every time.”
Madonna Wyant
Food-service director, St. Joseph-Ogden High School
“I would recommend shopping and taking advantage of the sales on your Thanksgiving meal items leading up to the days before.
“In our household, my husband is in charge of the turkey and he prefers to smoke it on his smoker. He injects it and smokes it low and slow.
“My heart is happy when we cook the big meal and have family and friends over for fellowship and watching football.”
Kenny Hogue
Owner/chef, Cast Iron Pub of Tuscola
“Go with what you know.
“Big meals are not the time to try out new recipes. You’ll have a much easier time timing out your service and have less stress if you’ve already made your dishes before.”