‘Gay cake’: Ashers Bakery case to be heard at Supreme Court


Gareth Lee's requested cake design


Two years ago, gay rights activist Gareth Lee was refused a cake with the slogan ‘Support Gay Marriage’

A Northern Ireland bakery found to have discriminated for refusing to make a “gay cake” will have its appeal heard by the Supreme Court later on Tuesday.

Ashers Bakery are challenging the ruling over their decision – in 2014 – not to make a cake iced with the slogan “Support Gay Marriage”.

Appeal court judges upheld the original decision in 2016.

The Supreme Court will hear the case on Tuesday and Wednesday during its first-ever hearings in Northern Ireland.

  • Timeline: Bakery discrimination case
  • ‘Gay cake’ row Q&A

It is only the second time the Supreme Court, established in 2009, has sat away from its permanent home in London Last June the court held four days of hearings in Edinburgh.

Press Eye


Daniel McArthur from the family-run firm Ashers was in court on Monday with his wife Amy to hear the outcome of the appeal

The court’s judgement on whether the owners of Ashers Bakery were guilty of unlawful discrimination is expected to be handed down later in the year, or possibly in early 2019.

‘Gay cake’ back in court

by Chris Page, Ireland correspondent

This court case is a clash over rights, freedom and faith – and it’s focused on a cake.

In 2014, a gay rights activist, Gareth Lee, made an order in Ashers Bakery in Belfast city centre.

He wanted a cake with a slogan in support of the campaign to legalise same-sex marriage in Northern Ireland. But the owners of Ashers said that was at odds with their Christian beliefs.

A judge ruled the bakery discriminated against Mr Lee on the grounds of his sexuality. Ashers lost an appeal against that judgement.

Now they’re taking the case to the highest court in the UK. Five Supreme Court judges will hear the arguments in Belfast later on Tuesday.

Tuesday marks the latest legal chapter in the long-running case that began in May 2014 when the order was placed at an Ashers shop in Belfast by gay rights activist Gareth Lee.

Ashers refused to bake the cake but were later found to have discriminated against Mr Lee.

Press Eye


The case was taken by gay rights activist Gareth Lee

The Christian owners of the bakery have repeatedly challenged the ruling.

The firm argued that the cake’s message was against the bakers’ religious views.

Their move to take the case to the Supreme Court came after Appeal court judges said that, under law, the bakers were not allowed to provide a service only to people who agreed with their religious beliefs.